The Competency Restoration Crisis: Why Defendants Wait Months in Jail — and What Scalable Training Can Do

The competency restoration crisis: defendants waiting in jail.

Introduction

In jurisdictions across the country, the same scene repeats: a court finds a defendant incompetent to stand trial, orders restoration — and then the case stalls, sometimes for months, while the defendant waits in jail for a restoration bed that may never come open in time. It has become one of the most persistent bottlenecks in the criminal-justice and behavioral-health systems. It’s worth understanding why it happens, and what can actually be done about it.

Anatomy of a bottleneck

The crisis is structural. Restoration has historically run through inpatient forensic hospitals, and those beds are a fixed, scarce resource. When demand exceeds them, the system improvises: defendants receive restoration in jails never designed for it, decompensate in resource-poor settings, and cycle back through the process. Meanwhile they wait — and prolonged pretrial detention of someone who hasn’t been tried raises real due-process concerns, which is why some jurisdictions impose firm timelines (such as limits on how long a defendant may wait for a hospital transfer). The timelines exist precisely because the delays are harmful.

Why the system can’t simply add beds

The intuitive fix — build more forensic beds — runs into hard limits of cost, staffing, and time. But there’s a more fundamental issue: a large share of these defendants never needed an inpatient bed at all. When incompetence is driven by knowledge gaps, cognitive limitations, or developmental immaturity rather than acute psychiatric crisis, an expensive hospital placement isn’t the right level of care. Pouring more capacity into the most intensive setting solves the wrong end of the problem.

Scalable, standardized, remote

The leverage point is to change what restoration runs on. A standardized, remote-capable training program scales to a caseload rather than a bed count. Because the MCAT Program’s curriculum and tools live in an online portal, an agency can begin restoration immediately, deliver it where the defendant already is — community, custody, or video — and serve more people without building a single new ward. And because it’s standardized and measured, that scale doesn’t come at the cost of rigor: every defendant moves through the same evidence-based four phases, with progress documented along the way. It’s a shift from a capacity the system can’t easily expand to one it can.

The piece everyone forgets: juveniles

If adult capacity is thin, juvenile capacity is thinner — and the tooling barely exists. The field has lacked a standard, accepted restoration curriculum for youth, and, as the J-MCES literature notes, there have been “no known competency assessments with established psychometric properties standardized for juvenile populations.” That leaves juvenile courts making high-stakes decisions with borrowed adult tools. A program that ships a dedicated juvenile curriculum alongside a juvenile-normed instrument doesn’t just add capacity — it fills a gap that was largely empty.

From crisis to program

None of this requires a defendant to wait for a system-level fix. Individual agencies — county behavioral-health and hospital systems, regional centers, probation, forensic practices — can stand up their own standardized restoration programs and start moving cases now. What that takes, from staffing to workflow, is the subject of Building an End-to-End Competency Program.

Stop letting cases wait on a bed. The MCAT Training Subscription gives your agency a scalable, remote-capable restoration program for adults and juveniles — see plans and pricing, plus CE at a subscriber discount.

Explore the MCAT Training Subscription →


Related Posts

Subscribe to newsletter

Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every week.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA. Google's Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Related posts

Building an End-to-End Competency Program Your Court Will Trust

5 minutes read

More Than Legal Knowledge: Why Modern Competency Tools Must Measure Risk and Emotional Regulation

3 minutes read

Juvenile Competency Isn’t Adult Competency in Miniature

Consult with us and Let us Answer Your Questions!

Learn more about our